Monday, September 15, 2008 at 6:59 am
Aren't you sort of glad Congress repealed Glass-Steagall?
Was deregulation a factor in bringing us to our financial system to its current teetering state? Yeah, sure. But the deregulatory decision most often cited by lefty (and not so lefty) observers--the 1999 repeal of the Depression-era Glass Steagall Act that had separated depositary banking from investment banking--is actually looking pretty good this Monday morning.
Without Glass-Steagall repeal, Bank of America wouldn't be able to buy Merrill Lynch, the only bit of arguably positive news to come out of this crazy weekend. And more generally, it is looking like investment banks that don't have big consumer banking franchises aren't up to the challenge of surviving modern-day financial crises. Of the five big independent investment banks that existed six months ago, only two survive.
Now it is true is that we failed to replace the archaic Glass-Steagall rules with a sensible, modernized regulatory structure. But don't worry, we'll be getting to that soon enough!
9 Comments to “Aren't you sort of glad Congress repealed Glass-Steagall?”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
About Curious Capitalist
RSS Feed
Daily Email
Recent Posts
The Curious Capitalist - TIME.com Archives
Blogroll
- Adam Lashinsky
- Amit Varma
- Barry Ritholtz
- Brad DeLong
- Calculated Risk
- Econbrowser
- Econlog
- Ezra Klein
- Felix Salmon
- Floyd Norris
- Going Private
- Greg Mankiw
- Herb Greenberg
- James Pethokoukis
- John Gapper
- Marginal Revolution
- Mark Thoma
- Matt McAlister
- Megan McArdle
- Michael Mandel
- Mike Moffatt
- Nicholas Carr
- Paul Kedrosky
- Roger Parloff
More TIME Blogs
Top Stories
- Why Obama Wants Hillary for His 'Team of Rivals'
- Is Mark Cuban Guilty of Insider Trading?
- In Zimbabwe, Mugabe Clings On, But His Power Is Waning
- BlackBerry Storm: The Novelty Wears Off Fast
- John Boehner Talks About the GOP's Plight in Congress
- As Somali Pirates Get Bolder, Policing Them Gets Tougher
- Stressed Out Hong Kong: Now, More Stressed Out
- Ford Might Be the Winner if the Auto Bailout Fails
- Why the Democrats - and Obama - Forgave Lieberman
- 'Saved by Zero': The Toyota Ad That Won't Stop
Top Photoessays and Slideshows
- Photos: The Brazen Pirates of Somalia
- The Politics of Water in Central Asia
- Pictures of the Week
- Mass Suicide at Jonestown: 30 Years Later
- Fade to Black
- Bao Xishun, the World's Tallest Man
- Planet Earth: An Illustrated History
- Prince Charles Turns 60
- Barack Obama: The Best TIME Photographs
- Somalia's Face of Modern Piracy
Monday, September 15, 2008 at 9:15 am
your brain is all scrambled, justin, maybe are put from the shock of the shameful crashing of the war-profiteering loan-sharks on wall street and main streets whom you count as your friends, if you think one near-death thief buys another in an attempt to fake good health, LOLOL.
the real good news is, no one's buying the scam anymore!
we the people will run you spinsters and your patron thieves broke and put you in prison. when you and your scare-mongering ("too big to fail") thieves are sentenced for life time of hard labor, justice will be finally done.
Monday, September 15, 2008 at 11:31 am
My main question about all this is - is BofA really as sound as everyone says it is? My understanding is that BofA has some huge issues with credit cards and other types of loans that haven't fully risen to crisis levels yet. Everyone keeps talking about BofA and JP Morgan as the "saviors" for the system. But, JP Morgan from what I remember about your article on the Credit Default Swaps market dwarfs EVERYONE. If there is a meltdown in that market, to me that means that JP Morgan might be gone. From everything I'm reading, it might not be possible to avoid a meltdown of the CDS market, so then the Bear takeover simply bought time before both firms go down. To me, I think this BofA takeover of Merill can only buy time before circumstances take out the whole firm. Wasn't Citigroup this kind of idea and it seems to me that Citi is in desperate trouble. If that's the case, how was the repeal a good thing? More troubling is that AIG is in serious trouble. So, it seems to me that it might be a good thing to restrict organizations to specific spheres in order to prevent such a wide ranging catastrophe.
Also, my other question would be, how does it benefit the country if BofA and JP Morgan Chase are the only commercial/investment banks in the nation? I'm no authority on any of this, but I can't imagine that is in any way a healthy outcome for the nation. But, I guess only time will tell because I don't think anyone has an idea what's coming next.
Monday, September 15, 2008 at 11:37 am
Justin, I agree it seemed like that repeal may have been a good thing.
Please excuse my ignorance but is its repeal related to the changes in credit default swaps? And am I right in thinking that said changes are a big part of what caused this meltdown?
Monday, September 15, 2008 at 1:22 pm
@TomT: I'm kind of ignorant here too, but I don't see any connection between Glass-Steagall repeal and the rise of credit default swaps. What did happen is that Brooksley Born, as chairman of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, tried to impose some regulation on over-the-counter derivatives like credit default swaps in the late 1990s, and was thwarted by Congress and Bob Rubin's Treasury Department.
Monday, September 15, 2008 at 1:41 pm
Justin, by credit default swaps were deregulated by some amendment put into some bill by Phil Gramm, no?
Sorry to be lazy about fact checking this -- I'm busy today
Monday, September 15, 2008 at 1:48 pm
Just to be clear, I wasn't trying to imply that the repeal led to the CDS market. I only brought up the CDS market to illustrate that the "savior" side of the Bear deal in JP Morgan has some very large exposure to a different market that seems very shaky. My point to Justin is why should we all be happy that the repeal allowed BofA to buy Merill if it just extends the collapse of both firms for a while and potentially leads to severe downside for average Americans.
My next question is this - is it true that what BofA got was the ability to use commercial bank deposits to fund investment banking operations? That is what has been posted on different sites. If this is true, than this is truly not a good thing in my opinion because then BofA will just be using depositor funds to hide problems on its balance sheet until they can no longer do so and fail due to insolvency. I guess this means that JP Morgan will be doing exactly the same thing with Bear. Then this is transfered to the FDIC who doesn't have the money either.
Please, please, please say that they are wrong. Or if they are not wrong, please explain to me why this isn't going to result in the new BofA/Merill or JP Morgan/Bear becoming the #1 commercial banking failure in US history?
Wednesday, October 1, 2008 at 9:14 pm
Do you have brain fog or are you getting lessons from Sarah Palins school of thought. Before you post such an idiot comment, you should actually look up what Glass-Steagall is. Glass-Steagall was formed as a reaction to the Great Depression to prevent thousands of bank failures from ever to happen again. Now that the government got rid of it, we will have another Great Depression where half of all our banks will close because they are all linked to the financial banks. Because there is no Glass-Steagall, designed by the ultimate deregulator Phill Gramm, Citibank, Bank of America, and J.P. Morgan Chase, who bought the most toxic house loans, will become the mega monopoly banks that will control everybody's money at their beckon will, even as they overleveridge their own bank sheets with all our deposits. In time you will be sooooo sorry they got rid of Glass-Steagall when these banks rip you off and government bails them out because they are too big to fail. PLEASE READ THE LOS ANGELES TIMES ARTICLE WED, OCT 1,08 ARTICLE IN THE BUSINESS SECTION, "TOO BIG TO FAIL" OR LOOK UP GLASS STEAGALL IN WIKIPEDIA. PLEASE.
Wednesday, October 1, 2008 at 10:14 pm
Or, Ali123, you could read this:
http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1841981,00.html
Wednesday, October 15, 2008 at 12:09 am
نوكيا الشرق الاوسط
menokia Forum
منتديات
دليل المواقع
الألعاب الفلاشيه
الطب البديل
برامج نوكيا الجيل الثالث
Symbian S60,S80,S90 Applications
Nokia
News
Symbian S60,S80,S90 Games
Themes and Wallpapers
MMS - SMS Messages
Bluetooth and video
Ringtones
PC Applications
Health Section
mEnPDA Team
nokiame.org
المنتدى الإسلامي
عالم حواء
آخر الاخبار
برامج نوكيا
Directory
اضف موقعك
منتديات نوكيا
منتديات نوكيا
مركز تحميل
مركز تحميل
مركز تحميل
Site Map
RSS
HTML
الاعلانات
صور
themes
software
ringtones
messages
games
apps
KING
برامج الجيل الثالث العربية
برامج الجوال المعربه
تعريب برامج الجوال
التكنلوجيا
العاب الانجيج الجيل الثالث
برامج نوكيا الجيل الثالث
العاب نوكيا الجيل الثالث
ثيمات نوكيا الجيل الثالث
احدث اجهزة نوكيا
تصميم الثيمات
Apple iphone
افلام
نكات
توبيكات
كرة قدم
السيارات
نوكيا